Home
 
 
07 May 2008 @ 07:25 pm
comcast fail.  
Comcast's DVR is the only device I've ever owned that seems to consistently get worse with every firmware update. From the removal of useful shortcuts, to putting invasive advertising in the program guide reducing screen space for useful stuff (like program info). The last two updates have really got under my skin though.

After playing back a recorded program, it used to pop up a dialog asking if you wanted to delete it. This no longer happens. Instead you stare at a frozen image. When you press 'stop' the dialog appears (it also appears after 15 seconds of staring at the frozen screen). According to forum posts I found somewhere, this 'feature' was added because some customers (read as 'morons') felt "panicked" and "rushed" into making a decision. Comcasts official line is that this feature was added so that people could rewind from the end and watch the last scene of a program again. Sounds great. The best part is, this was always possible. Even when the dialog was onscreen.

The latest "feature" that drives me up the wall: The DVR box has an LCD on the front displaying the time, or the current station being watched. When in standby mode, it shows the time. This is really handy, it means I don't need another clock in the room. Or at least that was the case until the last firmware update. Now, after a period of inactivity (ie, whilst in standby for a while), the LCD powers off. I'd like to think there's some benefit to this, like saving power. However, due to comcasts ineptitude, the DVR box actually uses the same amount of power in standby mode as it does when powered up. Winning. Net result: I no longer get to put my DVR in standby mode. (Not that it ever did anything anyway).

Every time this gets under my skin, I get renewed enthusiasm to get mythtv set up. Then I remember what a pain in the ass that was the last time.
Tags: ,
 
 
( Post a new comment )
[info]jonsmirl on May 8th, 2008 12:53 am (UTC)
You can get Tivo for your Comcast DVR from Comcast. I agree that their firmware sucks, I have FIOS now and it uses the same hardware but their firmware works.
(Reply) (Thread) (Link)
(Anonymous) on May 8th, 2008 01:26 am (UTC)
MythTV
I agree MythTV installation used to really suck. Things have been getting steadily better.

Previously I had to compile ivtv (kernel modules and supporting stuff) for my Hauppauge cards, compile lirc for the remote control, and then play with MythTV's setup and other dependencies. Most of the time I gave up and just went with ATRPMS, which is somewhat seriously hostile to livna.

Recently I migrated my old setup to a new computer. Fedora 8 with livna and MythTV compiled from source was extremely easy to setup.
(Reply) (Thread) (Link)
[info]a9db0 on May 8th, 2008 02:00 am (UTC)
Myth not that bad
The recent version of myth isn't nearly the challenge to set up that it once was, especially if you utilize distro packages. There are packages out for both Fedora and Debian, and with the Mythbuntu and Mythdora distributions it's really a cinch.

Try it out again. You might never go back to Tivo.
(Reply) (Thread) (Link)
Hubert Figuiere[info]hub_ on May 8th, 2008 02:33 am (UTC)
could the MythTV box decode the "digital TV" that comes to your DVR?
(Reply) (Thread) (Link)
(Anonymous) on May 8th, 2008 09:01 am (UTC)
less arse pain
As others have said, mythtv is not so bad to setup these days.

Having said that I still need hand-hacked modules for my tuner card to get the remote working, and I have to run a HZ=1000 kernel to get decent responsiveness from the remote.
(Reply) (Thread) (Link)
mmcgrath[info]mmcgrath on May 8th, 2008 02:41 pm (UTC)
Their support isn't very good either...
Our screen goes green sometimes. When I call to find out whats up, they say "un plug in and plug it back in" when I say that it happens pretty regularly they say "yep, just unplug it."

When I asked how I could relay this issue to their technical support team I was told "There is no way to do that" f'ers.
(Reply) (Thread) (Link)