I've been thinking about just how much a nightmare video codecs are lately. The usual case that everyone complains about is the inability for Linux distros to ship various patented codecs. But when I thought about it, the problem is much bigger than Linux.

There's not a single operating system, or media playback device that will reliably play every single format that could be thrown at it. Not even close.

My OSX box gets kinda close thanks to perian, but still fails with many of the wmv variants amongst others. Windows also requires a bunch of apps & codecs installed. It's not just a Linux problem, and in honesty, never has been.

A few nights ago, I rigged up ushare, to see how the PS3 coped with its built-in media player. It failed pretty spectacularly. Other than MPEGs, almost nothing worked.

I've been toying with the idea of getting a PMP for a while, but it's the same story. I'm not particularly interested in re-encoding all my music again, and even more disillusioned at the thought of not being able to actually play most of the videos I have.

Free, open standards like vorbis should make all of this a non-issue. Yet hardware manufacturers seem reluctant to implement them. The workarounds of taking codecs from other OS's and running them in Linux seems to have become 'the norm' for playing back a lot of formats in Linux. This of course works great for x86, but all the embedded variants of Linux I've seen so far in media playback devices are running ARM, or MIPS, which means of course.. no playback of those formats.

I'd like to believe it's a problem that will eventually go away, but each seems to get worse, with yet another format we're unable to play back universally.